Aerosmith frontman Steven Tyler is facing renewed legal uncertainty after a judge agreed to reconsider key decisions in a long-running sexual assault lawsuit brought by a woman who alleges she was involved with the rock star when she was just 16.
The case, filed in 2022 by Julia Misley, formerly known as Julia Holcomb, has taken another unexpected turn after a fifth judge was assigned to oversee the proceedings in Los Angeles.
Misley alleges that Tyler groomed and sexually abused her during a relationship that began in 1973 and lasted approximately three years. She also claims that the singer used his fame and influence to gain control over her circumstances, including an arrangement that made him her legal guardian.
Tyler has denied the allegations. His legal representatives have previously argued that the relationship was consensual and that the claims should be dismissed under applicable statutes of limitation.
The latest development follows the unexpected withdrawal of Judge Patricia Young in September, just weeks before the case had been scheduled to go to trial. She recused herself after concerns emerged about discussions involving another judge who had previously been disqualified.
Newly assigned Judge Lawrence Riff has indicated that he is prepared to reconsider earlier rulings if either side requests it. Those decisions include the dismissal of most claims involving alleged incidents in Massachusetts, Oregon and Washington.
A portion of the lawsuit relating to alleged conduct in California had previously been allowed to proceed under the state’s legislation concerning historic child sexual abuse claims.
The new judge has scheduled the trial to begin on May 3, 2027, while further hearings are expected to examine the disputed legal decisions.
Tyler’s legal team has previously described the earlier dismissal of most claims as a significant victory for the singer. However, the latest development means the legal battle is far from over.
With another judge now overseeing the case, the proceedings could take a new direction as both sides prepare for the next stage.
