Dancing With the Stars viewers are reacting to the latest elimination after Guillermo Rodriguez and his professional dance partner, Witney Carson, were sent home during the competition’s first-ever “Super Bowl Night” on October 13.

The popular television personality, best known for his appearances on Jimmy Kimmel Live!, became the sixth celebrity contestant eliminated from Season 35. His departure came after the remaining couples performed routines inspired by memorable Super Bowl halftime shows, bringing a night of high-energy choreography and unexpected results to the ballroom.

Rodriguez and Carson performed a salsa to Bad Bunny’s “Tití Me Preguntó,” drawing on the Puerto Rican superstar’s halftime-show performance. Their routine brought plenty of personality to the dance floor, with Carson incorporating energetic choreography to help her partner embrace the fast-paced Latin dance.

The judges awarded the pair 22 out of 40 points, including a six from Carrie Ann Inaba, a five from Derek Hough, a six from guest judge Joe Buck and a five from Bruno Tonioli. Although the performance earned praise for its entertainment value, the score left them at the bottom of the leaderboard. When judges’ scores were combined with audience votes, their journey came to an end.

The elimination quickly became a talking point beyond the ballroom. On Jimmy Kimmel Live!, host Jimmy Kimmel reacted with disbelief, describing the result as “an outrage” and joking about the decision. His reaction reflected the affection Rodriguez had earned during his time on the competition.

Despite the disappointment, Rodriguez appeared grateful for the experience. He had brought humor and enthusiasm to the show, while Carson helped him develop his dancing skills week after week. Their partnership became one of the season’s more entertaining storylines, even as their scores frequently placed them near the bottom of the standings.

The result also highlights the unpredictable nature of Dancing With the Stars. Judges’ scores matter, but audience voting can dramatically affect which couples remain in the competition. A memorable performance does not always guarantee another week in the ballroom.

Meanwhile, the remaining celebrities will continue competing for the Len Goodman Mirrorball Trophy, with the pressure increasing as the field narrows.

For Rodriguez and Carson, the journey is over, but their partnership has left viewers with plenty to remember. Whether audiences agree with the outcome or believe the pair deserved another chance, their elimination has certainly sparked conversation.

Was Guillermo Rodriguez’s elimination fair, or should he and Witney Carson have stayed for another week?